Tuesday, 18 October 2016
Entrance: Making the Grade
Since the Ministry of Education announced that it was considering revamping the province's reporting structure, I have given a lot of thought to assessments and grades. Like Sarte and Hughes reflect at the end of their article, I have mixed feelings about grades and doing away with them. I agree that school work needs to be meaningful and doable and students need autonomy in order for them to be intrinsically motivated. And I believe this is my ultimate goal as an educator.
On the other hand, I feel like most of the "real world" does have grade-like feedback mechanisms. These might be as simple as job placements, promotions, and even a pay check. The world I have experienced does have a component of competition and even stress. It can be stressful to be in interviews for scarce job opportunities or make sales pitches for ideas or projects. However, experts (like Dr. Stan Kutcher who we heard a couple of weeks ago) tell us that stress should be faced and can even be good for us.
Similarly, I have had experiences where I have had intense external motivation involving exams and "grades". Both the CFP and CA professions have intense exams where you must teach a minimum grade to get your certification (with the CA exam is taken over a span of three days). While these were intense, I feel that I had a strong sense of accomplishment in passing these exams and becoming certified.
And I have been in intense intrinsically motivated programs where I have learned a lot of material. My Master's in Accounting was such that the emphasis was on learning rather than marks. Similarly, UBC's program seems to have a strong emphasis on mastery of teaching skills - it's basically, a pass or fail. I enjoy these programs because I place a high value on learning and applying new skills.
I think in a perfect world there is a mix of extrinsic and intrinsic motivation - a balance between external and internal rewards. However, I do not know how to tap into this for all learners. It seems that some students need marks to direct them. Moreover, I do not know how to make a universal reporting structure without marks. The closest structure I can think of is a competency-based exam where the emphasis is placed on what is known and what skills have been attained.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Thanks Terry! You've given a very well-balanced introspective view of this topic.
ReplyDelete