Saturday, 10 December 2016

Inquiry: Can we flip secondary/post-secondary accounting classes effectively?




https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=BfsLbGgUMDU&ebc=ANyPxKoi5k3wUNDHoVBiwdVzra7gPPNUk4wpiImvbFtyLMXpFKfHxePJVq-15nm5KlYhRfxuDJR0XATsF1ktcgT_J-5q1khHEg





Wednesday, 23 November 2016

Inquiry: Annotated Bibliography

Arbaugh, J. (2014). What might online delivery teach us about blended management education? 
     
     prior perspectives and future directions. Journal of Management Education 38(6). Retrieved from
   

I liked that this article laid out a lot of literature reviews which showed the effectiveness of blended learning, specifically looking at Management Education (including Accounting, Economics, Marketing, Finance and Business). It also had a good discussion of the activities that are typically delivered in class (exercises, Q&A, and group problems) and those outside of class (lectures, preliminary quizzes and exercises). It ended with posing some significant questions that I am interested in dealing with learner, instructor and subject attributes.

Ash, K. (2012). Educators view 'flipped' model with a more critical eye. Education Week. 32(2),

     S6-S7.

This is a thought-provoking examination of criticism towards the flipped classroom. Critics say it is just another form of lecture and point out that it not an answer for unmotivated students. I thought this article provided a good balance and also explored the positive features. It also had a good listing of concrete steps to implement a flipped classroom.

Bergmann, J. (2016, September 4). The best way to start a flipped class. Retrieved from

     http://www.jonbergmann.com/the-best-way-to-start-a-flipped-class/

In this blog, Jon explores the strategy of having students take the first ten minutes of class time to teach their classmates what the learned from the lecture at home. His video of this in action was powerful and it showed me a useful strategy to use when implementing the flipped classroom.

Bergmann, J. (2016, October) Flipped learning: no one size fits all. Flipped Learning Worldwide     
     
     Podcast. Podcast retrieved from

     http://flippedlearning.org/syndicated/flipped-learning-no-one-size-fits/

This podcast was unique in the Jon Bergmann, an early flipped learning pioneer, interviews another pioneer, Brian Gervase. Brian relates how he was instrumental in beginning a new school based on the flipped model. I liked Brian's focus on mastery learning and his accounts of different teacher's implementation practices of this model.

Butt, A. (2014). Student views on the flipped classroom approach: evidence from Australia. Business 

     Education & Accreditation. 6(1), Retrieved from

    http://www.theibfr2.com/RePEc/ibf/beaccr/bea-v6n1-2014/BEA-V6N1-2014.pdf#page=65

This study looked at undergraduate student satisfaction with flipped classrooms. 75% expressed favourable perceptions which is consistent with other studies. I thought this study was instructive since we often look at  flipped classrooms from the teacher perspective or the students' results. However, this study told us how students perceive flipped classrooms. I was impressed over their positive reactions and comments.

Findley-Thompson, S. & Mombourquette, P. (2014). Evaluation of a flipped classroom in an

     undergraduate business course. Business Education & Accreditation. 6(1), Retrieved from

     http://www.theibfr2.com/RePEc/ibf/beaccr/bea-v6n1-2014/BEA-V6N1-2014.pdf#page=65

This study was interesting in that it compared the results and student perceptions of  students in a traditional undergraduate business course with those of a flipped classroom. While the results were not significantly different, it is noteworthy that those in the flipped classroom reported more satisfaction for their learning experience based on more face time with their professor and more time to collaborate with their peers.

Hernández-Nanclares, N. & Pérez-Rodríguez, M. (2016). Students’ satisfaction with a blended
   
     instructional design: the potential of “flipped classroom” in higher education. Journal of 
     
     Interactive Media in Education. 2016(1), Retrieved from http://doi.org/10.5334/jime.397

The focus of this article was on student engagement and satisfaction with learning Economics through a flipped classroom design. The study found that students enjoyed learning more especially in the areas of critical thinking, collaboration and active learning. Given these results, I wonder why flipped classrooms are not more prevalent. Could it be the upfront learning and initial instructor investment in technology?

TEDx Talk. (2012, May 16). Flipping the classroom with FIZZ: Katie Gimbar & Dr. Lodge 
     McCammon [Video File]. Retrieved from https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=a5bYuYvl42I

I watched a number of TED Talks relating to the  topics of  flipped classroom and blended learning (I think I watched all of the ones available on this subject). I liked how the presenters demonstrated the flipped classroom through via video for their introduction. They also demonstrated the idea of a simple one-time only presentation. While other experts talked about spending hours on their short videos, this once only idea seemed more doable and undaunting. This was so doable that even their students were able to replicate the process for classroom project presentations.



Saturday, 19 November 2016

Entrance: More on Flipped Classrooms


After a lot of thought I decided to look further into flipped classrooms - with my CFP background, I was also drawn to the addressing financial literacy in schools but there was already a large group doing this. Since I first heard of flipped classrooms, I have been quite interested in this concept. It seems pretty revolutionary but has not seemed to take on a lot of traction in most schools. Through my inquiry, I plan to learn more about flipped classrooms in general and even explore their relationship with blended learning. My ultimate goal is to see if they would be a viable option for any of the business classes I teach (both in the secondary and post-secondary levels). I plan to explore online articles and videos and also partner with John who is placed with SA's who are implementing flipped classrooms for their upper level high school math classes.


Exit: A Shift Away From Marks


One viable alternative to strictly following a marks-based system in our schools is to shift to a competency-based system. This system would be similar to UBC's teacher education program, surgery residency and to an extent the CPA qualifying examination. In all of these professions there is a burden of proof that the candidate must exhibit proficiency in a set skill set in order to qualify for their respect certification. For instance, the teacher must prove through their Practicum that they can indeed teach. However, it should be pointed out that marks still played an important filter in determining entrance into these training programs. So it would appear for comparison purposes that we can not do away with marks completely.

Another current theme is self-assessment. In this model more accountability is placed upon the student to assess their learning and performance. This is a nice theory but I feel that its implementation would have to be carefully thought out as I feel there could be a lot of bias and impartiality. For instance, even with clear rubrics, I have observed certain personalities who are too critical of theirselves or too optimistic. Similarly, there are those who always rate theirselves average irregardless of standards and performance. I am interested to see how successful this will be in the upcoming years and I would like to find out what my sponsoring SA's feel about this and if they can point me to any examples uses successful self-assessments in my Practicum.

Tuesday, 18 October 2016

Entrance: Making the Grade


Since the Ministry of Education announced that it was considering revamping the province's reporting structure, I have given a lot of thought to assessments and grades. Like Sarte and Hughes reflect at the end of their article, I have mixed feelings about grades and doing away with them. I agree that school work needs to be meaningful and doable and students need autonomy in order for them to be intrinsically motivated. And I believe this is my ultimate goal as an educator.

On the other hand, I feel like most of the "real world" does have grade-like feedback mechanisms. These might be as simple as job placements, promotions, and even a pay check. The world I have experienced does have a component of competition and even stress. It can be stressful to be in interviews for scarce job opportunities or make sales pitches for ideas or projects. However, experts (like Dr. Stan Kutcher who we heard a couple of weeks ago) tell us that stress should be faced and can even be good for us.

Similarly, I have had experiences where I have had intense external motivation involving exams and "grades". Both the CFP and CA professions have intense exams where you must teach a minimum grade to get your certification (with the CA exam is taken over a span of three days). While these were intense, I feel that I had a strong sense of accomplishment in passing these exams and becoming certified.

And I have been in intense intrinsically motivated programs where I have learned a lot of material. My Master's in Accounting was such that the emphasis was on learning rather than marks. Similarly,  UBC's program seems to have a strong emphasis on mastery of teaching skills - it's basically, a pass or fail. I enjoy these programs because I place a high value on learning and applying new skills.

I think in a perfect world there is a mix of extrinsic and intrinsic motivation - a balance between external and internal rewards. However, I do not know how to tap into this for all learners. It seems that some students need marks to direct them. Moreover, I do not know how to make a universal reporting structure without marks. The closest structure I can think of is a competency-based exam where the emphasis is placed on what is known and what skills have been attained.


Monday, 17 October 2016

Exit: Slowly Shifting the Accounting Image



It's funny, in a pathetic way, that society sees accountants as boring, nerdy business people. It's been my biased experience that some of the best people in the world are accountants or accounting teachers. I think it's up to us to educate the rest of the world about this. I try to incorporate famous, popular accountants into my lesson plans (Chuck Liddel - UFC MMA Champion, Kenny G - Jazz Musician, John Grisham - Writer). Similarly, I try to make accounting fun by making it interactive, relevant and engaging by including "fun" videos like Colin Dodd's Debit-Credit rap: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=j71Kmxv7smk . Lastly, our greatest weapon to counter stereotypes is to model the type of accountants (or teachers) that we want the world to see. I think it is up to us and within our grasp to change society's perception by influencing one student and one accounting class at a time. 

Wednesday, 12 October 2016

Entrance: My Inquiry

Three (plus one general bonus area) topics that I am interested in learning more about are:
flipped classrooms,
blended learning, 
teacher resources shared database, and/or
using technology effectively in the classroom.

Exit: Changing Times

Our class discussion on "Math Wars" sparked some great group discussion. We shifted from the discussion of Math to teaching in general. We discusssed whether "new" is always better and discussed how many well-educated proponents of change succeeded with their own traditional education. I, personally, feel that there is a place for change and incorporating new ideas into our lesson plans. I don't think that this necessarily means we do away with the old but embrace both - the modern and the traditional teaching methods.

Furthermore, I think as educators we often stumble upon successful teaching models. I think we need to expect some bumps when trying to embrace new ideas or teaching methods. For instance, I think the new curriculum in BC has some very good goals like higher level thinking and more flexibility in teaching. However, from looking at some of the Secondary Business drafts, I wonder how carefully these were thought out or created. For instance, they seem to have grouped the Applied Skills classes altogether without tailoring the guidelines between the very different subject areas of Tech Ed, Home Ec and Business.


Finally, I think life and teaching is what we make if it. As a teacher, I believe that I am a professional who can create the change that I seek for my learners. I think we have the opportunity to embracebe this change and be the change we desire.

Wednesday, 5 October 2016

Entrance: A Place for Gardens

"Do gardens have a place in our current education system?"
In an age where students are becoming more digital and resources, like land for garden plots, are becoming scarce, I believe we owe it to our future generations to provide hands-on encounters with nature. I favour gardens for more than just  the pedogoical reasons, the curriculum outcomes and even Gardner's naturalistic intelligence - almost more aptly gardner's intelligence for this post. I simply think that gardening, including the weeding, is healthy for adults and children alike. For children, I believe it creates bonds with nature, provides real life models to learn about life and nature, and provides a healthy balance to our automated life.

As I was reading Gerofsky's article, I feel that there will be many opportunities to incorporate learning gardens into BC's new curriculum model which emphasizes student-directed learning. I believe it will be our challenge as educators to support our students in their garden exploration to help make their learning meaningful.

Tuesday, 27 September 2016

Entrance 2: Teaching with Tact

"Good teachers are intuitively aware that the daily activities of teaching and learning are conditioned by such subtle factors as the atmosphere of the school and classroom, by the relational qualities that pertain amongst students and teachers, and by the corporeal skills or embodied knowledge that teachers enact." (p. 5)
"As a result of the emphasis on reflective practice in teacher education programs, student teachers have been pressed to live up to the expectation that good teachers are reflective teachers. But they have not always learned where and how the reflective process should enter the life of teaching."(p.12)
"My practical knowledge “is” my felt sense of the classroom, my feeling who I am as a teacher, my felt understanding of my students, my felt grasp of the things that I teach, the mood that belongs to my world at school, the hallways, the staffroom, and of course this classroom." (p.18)

Van Manen's article caused me to reflect on what makes an expert teacher. Ironically, it almost makes me think of the whole nature versus nurture debate. Are master teachers born intuitively as described in the first quote above or is there a fundamental teacher training process where novice teachers are trained how to apply the basics, such as how to be reflective as in the second quote. I feel that it must be a combination of sorts and likely varies from individual to individual. For instance, I have been around great teachers who have had little formal teaching on the application or art of teaching and also known well-trained scholars who fall short of the master teacher status (who actually seem destined to mediocrracy through no apparent falt of their own). Similarly, some people seem to have a natural gift for teaching. These people have tapped into their teaching tact. They represent Van Manen's third quote. These teachers seem to constantly be in the zone and their "feelings" cause them and their students to succeed. I see this as the ultimate teaching goal. I also tend to think that training does help to develop this tact but ultimately it comes from experience (and unfortunately there are no shortcuts for experience).

Tuesday, 20 September 2016

Entrance 1: 100 Years and Still Going



While it is noteworthy that the thoughts of Grant and Zeichner from 1984 are still relevant today, I find it fascinating that Dewey's words are still going strong today. In our EDST 401 class we are going over Dewey's, "My Pedagogic Creed" and also an article from July 2016 by Nicholas Tampio. Clearly, Dewey has and is still influencing generations of teachers and teacher candidates.

From Grant and Zeichner I reflect on how important reflection is. As I read the article I began to see why there is such an emphasis at UBC on reflection and inquiry. At first, I was surprised that there was not more emphasis on classroom management and teaching strategies. I was also shocked that after a few months we were being "loosed" upon a classroom of learners. However, after reading the article I can see how universal our first few months are and that the practicum, itself, is a great learning, reflective process/opportunity. I am now looking forward to learning from my faculty and student advisors and especially from the students who I will be teaching (and reflectively from myself).

Saturday, 17 September 2016

Exit 2: Frank McCourt and H. Douglas Brown

Today's illustration of Frank McCourt reminded my of my LLED 360 readings of H. Douglas Brown's 12 language teaching and learning principles, especially the 2nd and 4th principles. These principles of "meaningful learning" and "intrinsic motivation", respectively, seemed to be embodied in Frank McCourt and his teaching. Frank seemed to be able to empathize and make his lessons meaningful to his students (especially, the teacher obituaries and excuse letters). Because the assignments were interesting and engaging, his students were motivated to write and be on-task. It sounded like the assignments were creative and imaginative and that his students put a lot of effort into them. This reminds me of a marketing assignment I heard of where high school students were put in charge of the school store. They did all the research on which products to have in the store and how to advertise and market these products. Since the students could find meaning in their work, they were very engaged and learned a lot of the marketing principles in this hands-on environment. 

Exit 1: Paradigm Shift

Today we looked at Borasi's second controversial statement, "Staying too much on a problem is a waste of time". At first I was convinced that this was obviously false. Students need to learn persistence and 'stick-with-it-ness'. They need to learn that sometimes it is the learning process that is to be valued as much, and sometimes if not more, than the actual outcomes. However, as our group discussed this, I became aware that another valid view on this matter was to look at it from the time management perspective that emphasized using our time wisely. The emphasis on this viewpoint was that we have a finite amount of time and sometimes it is best not to keep spinning our wheels but to seek alternative solutions or spend time on other problems.

This new perspective came from our group discussion and the class discussion afterwards. I felt this was a good example of the value of group work and listening to others. If I would have done this assignment on my own I would have missed out on the second valuable insight dealing with time management. I am constantly reminded of the value of learning from others when I think of my children. They seem to always be "toddling" around asking millions of questions and of course they are constantly growing and learning as a result.

Thursday, 15 September 2016