Saturday, 19 November 2016

Exit: A Shift Away From Marks


One viable alternative to strictly following a marks-based system in our schools is to shift to a competency-based system. This system would be similar to UBC's teacher education program, surgery residency and to an extent the CPA qualifying examination. In all of these professions there is a burden of proof that the candidate must exhibit proficiency in a set skill set in order to qualify for their respect certification. For instance, the teacher must prove through their Practicum that they can indeed teach. However, it should be pointed out that marks still played an important filter in determining entrance into these training programs. So it would appear for comparison purposes that we can not do away with marks completely.

Another current theme is self-assessment. In this model more accountability is placed upon the student to assess their learning and performance. This is a nice theory but I feel that its implementation would have to be carefully thought out as I feel there could be a lot of bias and impartiality. For instance, even with clear rubrics, I have observed certain personalities who are too critical of theirselves or too optimistic. Similarly, there are those who always rate theirselves average irregardless of standards and performance. I am interested to see how successful this will be in the upcoming years and I would like to find out what my sponsoring SA's feel about this and if they can point me to any examples uses successful self-assessments in my Practicum.

No comments:

Post a Comment