"Good teachers are intuitively aware that the daily activities of teaching and learning are conditioned by such subtle factors as the atmosphere of the school and classroom, by the relational qualities that pertain amongst students and teachers, and by the corporeal skills or embodied knowledge that teachers enact." (p. 5)
"As a result of the emphasis on reflective practice in teacher education programs, student teachers have been pressed to live up to the expectation that good teachers are reflective teachers. But they have not always learned where and how the reflective process should enter the life of teaching."(p.12)"My practical knowledge “is” my felt sense of the classroom, my feeling who I am as a teacher, my felt understanding of my students, my felt grasp of the things that I teach, the mood that belongs to my world at school, the hallways, the staffroom, and of course this classroom." (p.18)
Van Manen's article caused me to reflect on what makes an expert teacher. Ironically, it almost makes me think of the whole nature versus nurture debate. Are master teachers born intuitively as described in the first quote above or is there a fundamental teacher training process where novice teachers are trained how to apply the basics, such as how to be reflective as in the second quote. I feel that it must be a combination of sorts and likely varies from individual to individual. For instance, I have been around great teachers who have had little formal teaching on the application or art of teaching and also known well-trained scholars who fall short of the master teacher status (who actually seem destined to mediocrracy through no apparent falt of their own). Similarly, some people seem to have a natural gift for teaching. These people have tapped into their teaching tact. They represent Van Manen's third quote. These teachers seem to constantly be in the zone and their "feelings" cause them and their students to succeed. I see this as the ultimate teaching goal. I also tend to think that training does help to develop this tact but ultimately it comes from experience (and unfortunately there are no shortcuts for experience).